College football's top individual award will be handed out Saturday night in New York. And In the court of public opinion it appears the jury has made its decision on who will win. Those 12 fine citizens say it will likely be Colt McCoy, maybe Tim Tebow or even Mark Ingram. But your honor, if I may, I'd like to make some closing arguments on behalf of the defense.
Of the five finalists for the Heisman Trophy, there's just one defender. But he might be the best defensive player of the decade. He's Ndamukong Suh the game changing tackle from Nebraska. If Heisman voters want to get it right this time, Suh is your man.
His performance in the Big-12 championship game against Texas was an instant classic. He threw Texas offensive linemen and quarterback Colt McCoy around like ragdolls. Despite being double and triple-teamed most of the night, Suh recorded 4½ sacks and seven tackles for losses. It was the latest and greatest performance for the 6-4, 300-pounder in a dream season.
Hopefully before those ballots were cast voters went back and look at the many great Suh moments this season. Like the pick against Missouri. Or the four deflected passes against Virginia Tech? Or his three blocked field goals on special teams?
The Heisman is the big enchilada and I haven't read anywhere that it can't go to a defensive player. (Just ask Charles Woodson). Just because a game-changing player like Suh doesn't get the glamorous numbers like rushing yards and touchdown passes, it doesn't and shouldn't diminish his work. Against Texas, did his 4.5 sacks equal five or six TD passes? How about those seven tackles for loss? That's equal to about a dozen receptions.
Unfortunately for Suh and Nebraska fans he didn't play quarterback or running back. It wasn't his fault that Bo Pelini's anemic offense ranked 102nd out of 120 teams in yards per game. Despite the lack of offense against Texas, Nebraska was still in position to win. Thanks to one guy, the guy who should win the Heisman.
If online and newspaper polls are to be believed, then Suh doesn't have a chance.
Consider the following:
-- A poll on ESPN.com by 15 experts this week had McCoy winning, with Stanford running back Toby Gerhart a strong second and Florida quarterback Tim Tebow a distant third.
-- A Scripps Howard News Service poll of 10 Heisman voters had McCoy leading, with Tebow second and Gerhart a close third after jumping two spots in a week.
-- On the Heisman Pundit Web site's poll of 13 Heisman voters, McCoy beat Gerhart, with Alabama running back Mark Ingram third.
-- A poll among five experts on CBSSports.com had Gerhart edging McCoy in a close vote.
I'm not a Heisman voter but if I were, my ballot would look like this:
Su
Toby Gerhart
Colt McCoy
Mark Ingram
Tim Tebow
Suh is definitely a long shot to leave New York with the Heisman award. It looks like he'll have to be content with the Lombardi Award given to the nation's top lineman and the Bronco Nagurski award as the top defensive player in the country. And, Oh yeah, he'll probably be the top overall pick in the NFL draft. That won't be a half-bad consolation prize.
Here are the latest odds Heisman Trophy Odds:
Colt McCoy (+125)
Mark Ingram (-350)
Ndamukong Suh (+500)
Tim Tebow (+1500)
Toby Gerhart (+300)